
JEPQ vs GPIQ vs QQQI: Nasdaq Covered Call ETFs Reviewed by a CFA Charterholder
About this article: This article is based on Ethan’s video, originally published on November 5, 2024. Because the written version was published later, returns, yields and fund details reflect data available at the time of the video and have likely changed since. Please check each fund’s website for current figures.
JEPQ, GPIQ and QQQI are three of the most popular ways to collect a big monthly income from the Nasdaq 100. In this review I’ll show you how they stack up on the five things that matter most for a covered call ETF: income level, income consistency, long-term growth potential, downside protection and tax efficiency.
The Short Version
Income level: QQQI wins, and it’s likely to stay the highest of the three.
Income consistency: a tie between GPIQ and QQQI. JEPQ’s payouts have bounced around far more.
Long-term growth: a tie between GPIQ and JEPQ, with an asterisk. If you take the income out, I don’t think any of them win.
Downside protection: a tie between QQQI and JEPQ. GPIQ fell the most in all three recent dips.
Tax efficiency: QQQI, clearly.
What a Covered Call ETF Actually Does
At the most basic level, all three of these are covered call ETFs based on the Nasdaq 100. If you already know how that works, skip ahead to the next section.
A covered call ETF buys stocks, then writes, or sells, call options on them. A call option gives the buyer the right to buy a stock at a set price, called the strike price. They’ll only want to do that if the stock goes higher than that price. So if you’re the one selling those options, like these ETFs are, someone else gets the upside if the stocks go up a lot.
To recap: you get a little of the upside, and anything beyond the strike price you give up. What do you get in return? A massive yield. Since that’s the main reason people buy JEPQ, GPIQ and QQQI, let’s start there.
1. Income Level: QQQI Wins
On their fact sheets, QQQI showed the highest yield at 14.1%, JEPQ showed 12.3%, and GPIQ showed… 0.5%?
Look closely and they’re quoting different things. QQQI quotes its “distribution rate,” JEPQ quotes its “dividend yield” (the same calculation), and GPIQ only quotes its SEC yield, which doesn’t count the income from option premiums. That’s where most of the income comes from.
That distribution rate calculation is, frankly, total BS. It takes the most recent monthly payment, multiplies it by 12, and divides by the price at the last ex-dividend date. Run the same math on GPIQ and you get 10.7%. I like that Goldman Sachs doesn’t play that game.
In my opinion the only yield worth paying attention to for stock funds is the 12-month distribution yield. It isn’t a perfect predictor either, but anything based on 12 months of data beats something that takes one month and assumes it will repeat forever. For funds that really chase income, like Roundhill’s weekly payers, the one-month number can jump around like crazy and tells you nothing about the future.
On a 12-month basis, GPIQ yielded 9.4% and JEPQ 9.6%. QQQI didn’t have a full year yet, but based on its first nine months of payouts I’d estimate roughly 14.4%.
Why QQQI Should Stay on Top
QQQI writes options on “up to” 100% of the portfolio, slightly out of the money, aiming for a consistent monthly income. “Up to” could mean anything, so I checked. Its holdings file showed 208 Nasdaq 100 option contracts sold. Each covers 100 “shares” of an index trading around 20,000, so the options covered about $416 million of a $555 million fund, roughly 75%. Its sister fund SPYI generally writes on 75–90% of assets, about 1–4% out of the money, and QQQI’s strike prices fit that range too.
The more of the portfolio you write options on, and the closer to the current price, the higher your income and the lower your upside. For comparison:
JEPQ sells options about 2.5% out of the money through equity-linked notes (ELNs) on up to 20% of the portfolio. That 20% is misleading: ELNs can include leverage and options are leveraged by nature. Based on monthly payouts of roughly 0.8–1.2% and its limited upside, I’d guess its real option exposure covers most, but not all, of the portfolio.
GPIQ sells options at or near the money on anywhere from 25% to 75% of the portfolio. Like QQQI, it aims to keep income steady, so with a yield around 9–10% so far, I don’t expect it to jump past 14%.
JEPQ’s yield is likely to drift down over time, while QQQI will probably give up more upside to defend its yield if volatility and interest rates fall. So on income level, QQQI wins, and I expect it to stay that way.
2. Income Consistency: GPIQ and QQQI Tie
GPIQ and QQQI are both managed specifically to keep income consistent. JEPQ is not, and it shows. Comparing their monthly payouts per share (from 2023 for JEPQ, and since launch for the other two), QQQI’s and GPIQ’s have stayed pretty steady despite short track records, while JEPQ’s has bounced around like crazy. It was back down to 49 cents in November 2024.
You could nitpick that GPIQ has been slightly steadier than QQQI, but both are so much more consistent than almost every other covered call ETF that I’m calling it a tie. If you really want a perfectly steady paycheck, stop relying on dividends of any kind and set up a systematic withdrawal plan.
3. Long-Term Growth Potential: A Tie, With an Asterisk
Even if growth isn’t why you bought these, it matters, because it decides how long your income lasts. A 9% yield is 9% of the fund’s value. If that value shrinks over time, so does your income, even if the percentage stays the same. Sadly, we can’t buy groceries with percentages. To keep up with inflation you need something that grows.
(This assumes you take all the income out. Any of these can build a growing income stream if you reinvest the dividends, but I know most people don’t want to.)
JEPQ has been around the longest. Since launch, its price rose about 6.5% while the Nasdaq 100 rose almost 50%, both without dividends. In total return it held up better in the downturn, but if you were taking the income, that price line is what your yield was paid on. Its payouts started at 55 cents, then 58 cents, and they’ve been trending down since. Is that what you want your retirement paychecks to look like? I know I wouldn’t.
So JEPQ gave up almost all of the upside while paying a declining yield, in a very favorable environment. For an investor taking out every dividend, I think the odds of it producing an income that keeps pace with inflation over several decades are close to zero.
QQQI and GPIQ have very short track records, all in strong bull markets, so take this with a grain of salt. QQQI’s price rose only 2% while QQQ rose 15%. GPIQ has captured somewhat more of the Nasdaq’s upside than the other two, but over the same period as QQQI it was only slightly ahead of JEPQ.
That makes sense. All three hold nearly the same stocks, and GPIQ and JEPQ have paid out about the same. QQQI paid more, and the way you get a higher yield is by giving up more upside. It’s a direct trade-off.
Between GPIQ and JEPQ it’s too close to call. GPIQ is 6 basis points cheaper, which helps a little. The bigger wild card is volatility: when it’s high, option income is high, so GPIQ can sell fewer options to hit its target and keep more upside. When it’s low, it has to sell more and cap more. So I’m calling GPIQ and JEPQ a tie.
But it’s a tie with an asterisk. If you reinvest the dividends, I’d give the edge to GPIQ and JEPQ. If you take the income out, like most people do, I don’t think any of them has much chance of producing a growing income that keeps up with inflation.
4. Downside Protection: QQQI and JEPQ Tie
There haven’t been many downturns since QQQI launched, so here are the three biggest, with dividends reinvested. (Fun fact: their total returns since QQQI’s launch were remarkably close at the time, around 14%, 15% and 13.9%.)
April 11–19, 2024: almost no difference. JEPQ fell the least and GPIQ the most, only 0.24% apart.
July 10 – August 7, 2024: GPIQ fell about 1% more than the others. QQQI held up 0.14% better than JEPQ.
August 30 – September 6, 2024: GPIQ fell the most at −5.3%, QQQI fell 4.8%, and JEPQ fell the least at 4.02%.
These weren’t big downturns and the gaps weren’t huge, but GPIQ lost the most every time. Between QQQI and JEPQ there hasn’t been enough difference to pick a winner, and nothing in their strategies suggests one should protect better than the other. So it’s a tie.
5. Tax Efficiency: QQQI Is the Clear Winner
Remember how JEPQ showed a much higher SEC yield (11.4%, versus 0.5% for GPIQ and 0.2% for QQQI)? Here’s why. JEPQ doesn’t write covered calls directly; it uses equity-linked notes, so all of its option income is taxed as ordinary income, a higher rate than dividends or long-term capital gains for most people. My guess is they do it because it lets them show the option income in their SEC yield. It looks good on paper, but it means lower after-tax returns for shareholders.
GPIQ doesn’t do much for tax efficiency either. It sells options on index-linked products like ETFs, and since those positions are held under a year, the income is taxed at ordinary income rates.
QQQI is the only one of the three truly managed for taxes, in three ways:
Owning individual stocks. The small part of its income that comes from dividends is mostly “qualified,” taxed at a top rate of 20% (15% for most people, 0% for some, under 2024 rules; check the IRS for current rates).
Selling options on the index itself. Options written on an index like the Nasdaq 100, rather than on an ETF that tracks it, are usually taxed 60% at the lower long-term capital gains rate and 40% at the short-term rate. In a high tax bracket, that’s a big advantage over JEPQ and GPIQ, whose income is mostly or entirely taxed at the higher rate. The prospectus notes proposed regulations could remove this benefit, but for now it stands.
Active tax management. At any time, some holdings are up and some are down. QQQI can harvest losses against gains as it trades, which lets it classify part of its payouts as “return of capital.” That portion isn’t taxed in the year you receive it. You still pay eventually, but long-term investors can defer taxes and potentially pay the lower long-term rate on more of their gains.
The Verdict, and Why I Wouldn’t Own Any of Them
Each ETF beats the others on something, and there’s no clear winner across the board. It depends what matters most to you. But in my opinion, none of these should be relied on alone for retirement income. They’re all covered call ETFs: you give up a lot of the upside and keep most of the downside. That’s not a great deal, and it’s not likely to create a sustainable, growing income. I know that might rain on your parade, so here are two reasons.
1. They’ve Only Lived Through Ideal Conditions
So far these ETFs have only existed with high volatility and high interest rates, which both mean bigger option premiums. If rates fall and tech calms down, JEPQ’s yield could drop, and GPIQ and QQQI would have to write more calls, capping more upside, to keep their payouts steady. The Nasdaq has also had huge returns since each launched, so we haven’t seen their real downside yet.
2. The Strategy Itself Is Built to Struggle
All three invest in the Nasdaq (or something close) and write calls slightly out of the money, capping their monthly upside at roughly 2–3%. How often does the Nasdaq go up more than that in a month? Over the last 20 years (240 months), it rose more than 2% almost half the time, and more than 3% almost 40% of the time. Often it rose way more. A lot of a volatile index’s gains come in short bursts, and if you miss those while still taking most of the big drops, it’s a tough long-term setup.
How tough? The Nasdaq returned just over 13.5% a year over those 20 years. If you’d missed every monthly gain above 3%, you would have lost over 1% a year. Miss every gain above 2%, and you’d have lost over 6% a year. And that was a great stretch for the Nasdaq.
So if you reinvested payouts like these, you’d be fine. But if you took them out as income, there’s a good chance you’d be down, maybe by a lot, and your income would be too. That’s not a 20-year retirement plan. The past isn’t a perfect predictor, and details like writing calls on 70% of the portfolio instead of 100% change the math. But conceptually, this is why I wouldn’t touch any of these with a 10-foot pole. They look good now with their cute one- or two-year track records, but I don’t think they’ll work out the way a lot of people hope.
And compared with the S&P 500 versions of these funds, you aren’t getting much more yield for a lot more risk. If you believe in the upside of tech stocks, why buy an ETF that caps it? If high income is what you’re after, I think the S&P 500 covered call ETFs are the better options.
Watch the Full Video
Want to Go Deeper? In the Fundamentals of Finance Academy, Ethan breaks down funds and current market events on a live call every other week, and members get the full archive of recorded calls. Learn more about the Academy →

This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. Ethan is a CFA charterholder, but nothing here is a recommendation to buy or sell any security, and it does not take your personal situation into account. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Charts of index returns are for illustration only and don’t reflect the fees, expenses or taxes of any actual investment. Performance data and fund details are as of 11/05/2024 and will change; check each fund’s website for current figures.